Tale of the Tape - Who is our best batsman in the past 12 months?

Brendon??

Or

Kane??

Brendon has scored heavily in three test innings but is this enough to topple young Kane off the averages and runs scored in a calendar year perch?

In the spreadsheet below I have tallied all test innings, all ODI innings and all T20 innings seperately to give a synopsis of how they went in all three forms.  You'd think no surprises right?  And to get a balance of how well both batsmen have progressed through the year, a match up at the end of their combined runs from all three forms and a combined average.

Intrigued to see how they fared and who is best?

The stats.

Williamson		B McCullum
Tests	NO	Tests	NO
45		37
58		12
56		224
113		1
3		8
47		302
7		7
113		17
2		4
42	1	3
161		31
3		25
23		18
32		39
11		43
192		45
		202
908		1018		Runs scored
60.53		63.63		Average
ODI's	NO	ODI's	NO
8		51
47		33
16		14
71		6
77		30
65		0
60		0
88		49	1
10		23
70	1	16
		12
512		234		Runs scored
56.89		21.27		Average
T20's	NO	T20's		NO
24	1	60		1
51		17
29		16		1
42		4
19		65
37		0
0		40
32		21
234		223		Runs scored
29.25		37.17		Average
Kane		Bmac
1654		1475		Total from 11 December 2013 to 13 December 2014
51.69		44.70		Average across all forms.